The Harms and Benefits of Large Language Systems: An In-depth Analysis of Accuracy and Its Impact

Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a transformative force in artificial intelligence, demonstrating remarkable capabilities in understanding and generating human-like text. These models are rapidly being integrated into various sectors, from customer service to healthcare and education, promising to revolutionize workflows and enhance human-computer interactions. In fact, LLMs are leading to a paradigm shift in software architecture, as natural language now becomes a core feature in software engineering 1. Instead of relying on rigid, predefined interfaces, users can now interact with software using natural language, increasing the reliance on LLM accuracy and raising the stakes for potential errors. However, alongside their potential benefits, LLMs also present significant challenges, particularly concerning their accuracy and the potential consequences of their outputs on human decision-making. This article delves into the intricate relationship between the accuracy of LLMs, the conclusions drawn from their outputs, and the resulting harms and benefits across various domains.

Accuracy and Reliability of LLMs: A Critical Examination

Data Quality and Bias

The accuracy of LLMs is a multifaceted issue with far-reaching implications. While these models have shown impressive performance on various tasks, including question answering, text summarization, and translation, they are not infallible. LLMs can generate outputs that are factually incorrect, biased, or even entirely fabricated, a phenomenon often referred to as “hallucination” 2. This tendency to produce plausible-sounding but inaccurate information poses a significant challenge, particularly in scenarios where reliable information is crucial for decision-making.

One primary factor contributing to these accuracy limitations is the nature of the data used to train these models. Many LLMs are trained on massive datasets of text and code scraped from the internet, which can contain inaccuracies, biases, and outdated information 4. Consequently, the models may learn and perpetuate these flaws, leading to outputs that reflect the biases or inaccuracies present in the training data. For example, if an LLM is trained on a dataset that contains biased language or stereotypes, it may generate outputs that reinforce those biases, potentially leading to discrimination or unfair treatment. However, it’s important to note that some LLMs are trained on curated datasets with a focus on accuracy and safety, such as Anthropic’s Claude 3.5 Sonnet 6. These models undergo more rigorous data selection and filtering processes to minimize the risk of bias and inaccuracies.

Probabilistic Nature of LLMs

Another factor affecting LLM accuracy is their inherent probabilistic nature. These models generate text by predicting the likelihood of word sequences based on patterns learned from the training data 3. This probabilistic approach, while enabling fluid and human-like text generation, can also lead to inconsistencies and inaccuracies, as the model may not always select the most factually accurate or contextually appropriate response. This inherent variability in outputs can be further compounded by the fact that machine learning models, including LLMs, are not deterministic 7. For the same user input, an LLM may produce different responses due to the probabilistic nature of the underlying algorithms. This variability can lead to inconsistencies in decision-making when relying on LLMs, potentially causing harm in high-stakes situations.

Accuracy Fluctuations

Furthermore, studies have shown that the accuracy of LLMs can fluctuate over time and across different topics 8. For instance, a study by researchers at Stanford and Berkeley found that the performance of LLMs on tasks like solving mathematical problems and generating code varied significantly over time, with GPT-4’s accuracy in certain tasks dropping dramatically 8. This variability in accuracy poses a challenge for applications that require consistent and reliable outputs, particularly in high-stakes domains like healthcare or finance. Additionally, research indicates that the accuracy of LLMs can differ significantly across various topics. A study by Originality.ai found that LLMs demonstrated the highest average accuracy in the health domain (80.5%) and the lowest in the news domain (64.4%) 9. This highlights the importance of considering domain-specific accuracy when evaluating LLMs for specific applications.

Model Autophagy Disorder (MAD)

A concerning phenomenon that can further impact LLM accuracy is Model Autophagy Disorder (MAD), identified in a study by Stanford and Rice University 10. MAD occurs when AI output quality dramatically decreases as systems are fed AI-generated content. This can create a feedback loop of decreasing accuracy, where LLMs trained on increasingly inaccurate AI-generated data produce even less accurate outputs. This phenomenon can have significant implications for human conclusions, potentially amplifying the harms discussed in this article, such as the spread of misinformation and bias amplification.

Larger LLMs and Simple Tasks

Interestingly, research has also shown that larger LLMs, despite their increased capabilities, may become less reliable in providing accurate answers to simple tasks 11. This counterintuitive finding challenges the assumption that larger models are always better and emphasizes the need for careful evaluation of LLM accuracy across different tasks. It suggests that simply increasing the size and complexity of LLMs may not always translate to improved accuracy, particularly for straightforward tasks where smaller, more focused models might perform better.

Impact of LLM Accuracy on Human Conclusions

The accuracy, or lack thereof, of LLMs directly influences the conclusions people draw from their outputs. When LLMs generate inaccurate or misleading information, users may unknowingly internalize these inaccuracies and form incorrect conclusions 5. This can have significant consequences, particularly in scenarios where decisions are made based on the information provided by the LLM.

For instance, in the legal domain, a lawyer relying on an LLM to prepare a legal brief might inadvertently cite nonexistent court cases if the model hallucinates legal precedents 2. This can lead to professional embarrassment, legal repercussions, and potentially even miscarriages of justice. Similarly, in healthcare, if an LLM used for medical diagnosis provides inaccurate information, it could lead to misdiagnosis, delayed treatment, or even harm to patients 12. A study published in the National Library of Medicine found that while LLMs like ChatGPT-4 showed promise in retrieving information on disease epidemiology, they still presented inaccurate responses, including fabricated references 13. This highlights the potential for LLMs to generate misleading information even in specialized domains, emphasizing the need for careful validation and human oversight in healthcare applications.

The tendency of LLMs to present information with a high degree of confidence, even when incorrect, further exacerbates this issue 11. This can lead users to place undue trust in the model’s outputs, potentially overlooking inaccuracies or failing to seek independent verification. Consequently, people may make decisions based on flawed information, with potentially harmful consequences.

Moreover, the “black box” nature of LLMs can make it challenging to understand how they arrive at their conclusions 14. This lack of transparency can make it difficult to identify and correct errors or biases, further increasing the risk of drawing incorrect conclusions from LLM outputs.

The Language-as-Fixed-Effect Fallacy

A study published on arXiv highlights a phenomenon called the “language-as-fixed-effect fallacy” 15. This fallacy occurs when seemingly insignificant changes in the wording of prompts can drastically affect LLM performance and user conclusions. The study found that even subtle modifications in prompts, such as using “plus” instead of “+” or rephrasing a question slightly, can lead to substantial differences in the LLM’s responses. This highlights the sensitivity of LLMs to the specific language used in prompts and the potential for misinterpretations or inaccurate conclusions if users are not meticulous in their interactions with these models.

LLMs in Business Applications

A study by Juan Sequeda, published in insideAI News, examined the accuracy of LLMs in answering questions over real business data from an insurance company 16. The study found that LLMs provided accurate responses to basic queries only 22% of the time, and accuracy dropped to 0% for intermediate or expert-level queries. This highlights the potential for significant errors when using LLMs in business applications, particularly for complex or specialized tasks. The study emphasizes the need for careful evaluation and potential integration with knowledge graphs to improve the accuracy and reliability of LLMs in business settings.

LLMs and Human Performance in Text Analysis

A study published in DoBetter, ESADE, examined the capacity of LLMs to analyze news articles and compared their performance to that of human coders 17. The study found that LLMs demonstrated “unprecedented accuracy” in analyzing the news articles, consistently outperforming human coders in tasks that required deep contextual knowledge and interpretation. This highlights the potential for LLMs to surpass human capabilities in certain text analysis tasks, potentially leading to more efficient and accurate analysis of large volumes of text data. However, the study also acknowledges the need for careful evaluation and the potential for biases in LLM outputs, which can affect the validity of conclusions drawn from their analysis.

Harms and Benefits of LLM-Driven Conclusions

The conclusions drawn from LLM outputs can result in a range of harms and benefits, depending on the context and the accuracy of the information provided.

Potential Harms

• Misinformation and Disinformation: LLMs can be exploited to generate and spread misinformation, potentially leading to harmful consequences. For example, an LLM could be used to create fake news articles or social media posts that appear credible, influencing public opinion or inciting violence 4. A study by researchers at the Oxford Internet Institute, published in Nature Human Behaviour, highlights the risk that LLMs pose to science due to their potential to generate false or misleading information 18. The study emphasizes the need for caution and responsible use of LLMs in academic settings to prevent the spread of misinformation and protect scientific truth.
• Bias Amplification: LLMs can amplify biases present in their training data, leading to outputs that perpetuate societal prejudices and stereotypes 4. This can have detrimental effects on marginalized groups, potentially reinforcing discrimination or limiting opportunities.
• Privacy Breaches: LLMs can inadvertently expose sensitive information, either through data leakage from their training data or by retaining information from user inputs 3. This can lead to privacy violations and potential harm to individuals.
• Erosion of Trust: As LLMs become more prevalent, the potential for generating inaccurate or misleading information could erode public trust in information sources and institutions 9. This could have far-reaching consequences for society, potentially hindering informed decision-making and undermining democratic processes.

Potential Benefits

• Increased Efficiency and Productivity: LLMs can automate various tasks, such as summarizing documents, generating reports, and translating languages, leading to increased efficiency and productivity in various sectors 19.
• Improved Decision-Making: When used responsibly and with appropriate oversight, LLMs can provide valuable insights and assist in making informed decisions. For example, in healthcare, LLMs can analyze patient data and medical literature to support clinical decision-making, potentially leading to improved patient outcomes 21.
• Enhanced Creativity and Innovation: LLMs can be used to generate creative content, such as poems, scripts, and musical pieces, potentially fostering innovation and pushing the boundaries of human expression 22.
• Improved Accessibility: LLMs can be used to create tools that improve accessibility for people with disabilities, such as text-to-speech and speech-to-text applications, making information and technology more inclusive 23.

LLMs in Specific Sectors: Accuracy and Its Impact

The impact of LLM accuracy varies across different sectors, with some domains being more sensitive to inaccuracies than others.

Education

In education, LLMs are being used for tasks such as personalized learning, automated grading, and content generation 23. A survey paper published on arXiv provides a comprehensive overview of LLM technologies in educational settings, highlighting their potential benefits and challenges 25. The survey emphasizes the potential for LLMs to personalize learning experiences, streamline administrative tasks, and enhance student engagement. However, it also acknowledges the risks associated with LLMs, such as plagiarism, bias in AI-generated content, and overreliance on technology.

The accuracy of LLMs is crucial in this context, as inaccurate information could mislead students or hinder their learning. For example, if an LLM used for tutoring provides incorrect explanations or generates biased content, it could negatively impact students’ understanding and perpetuate harmful stereotypes 26. Furthermore, there is concern that over-reliance on LLMs could hinder the development of critical literacy skills, including reading and writing 27. If students rely too heavily on LLMs to summarize or generate text, they may miss opportunities to develop their own comprehension and critical thinking abilities, potentially affecting their long-term academic success.

Healthcare

In healthcare, LLMs are being explored for applications such as clinical decision support, medical documentation, and patient communication 28. A study published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research highlights the potential benefits and challenges of using LLMs in healthcare 30. The study emphasizes the potential for LLMs to enhance clinical decision support, improve patient care, and streamline administrative tasks. However, it also acknowledges the need for careful evaluation, addressing ethical and societal implications, and mitigating biases while maintaining privacy and accountability.

The accuracy of LLMs is paramount in this domain, as errors could have serious consequences for patient health. For instance, an inaccurate diagnosis or treatment recommendation based on LLM output could lead to misdiagnosis, delayed treatment, or even patient harm 31. A study published in Forbes highlights the potential for LLMs to assist with clinical diagnoses, but also emphasizes the need for tailoring LLMs to specific operational needs and rigorous data management 32. Additionally, there are concerns about the potential privacy risks associated with using LLMs in healthcare, especially when sending medical data to external servers 21. Privacy breaches could have serious consequences for patients, potentially leading to identity theft, discrimination, or misuse of sensitive medical information.

Legal System

In the legal system, LLMs are being used for tasks such as legal research, document review, and contract analysis 33. A study published in the Melbourne University Law Review explores the impact of LLMs on dispute processes in law, highlighting their potential to revolutionize legal research and e-discovery 34. The study emphasizes the potential for LLMs to enhance efficiency, reduce costs, and improve accuracy in legal tasks. However, it also acknowledges the challenges associated with LLM adoption, such as the risk of hallucinations and the need for transparency and accountability.

The accuracy of LLMs is crucial in this context, as errors could have legal ramifications or even lead to miscarriages of justice. For example, an LLM that hallucinates legal precedents could mislead lawyers or judges, potentially influencing legal decisions or undermining the fairness of legal proceedings 34. A study published in the Tulane Freeman School of Business News explored the use of AI in sentencing and found that while AI tools can help reduce jail time for low-risk offenders, racial bias can still persist 35. This highlights the need for careful evaluation and ongoing monitoring to ensure that AI tools used in the legal system do not perpetuate existing biases or lead to unfair outcomes.

Mitigating the Risks and Maximizing the Benefits

To mitigate the risks associated with LLM accuracy and maximize their potential benefits, several strategies are crucial:

• Improving Data Quality: Ensuring that the training data used for LLMs is accurate, unbiased, and up-to-date is essential for improving the reliability of their outputs 36. This involves careful data selection, filtering, and ongoing updates to ensure that the models are learning from the most reliable and representative information.
• Developing Robust Evaluation Metrics: Developing comprehensive evaluation metrics that go beyond simple accuracy measures and assess factors such as bias, fairness, and explainability is crucial for ensuring that LLMs are used responsibly 37. These metrics should capture the nuances of LLM performance across different tasks and domains, providing a more holistic view of their capabilities and limitations.
• Promoting Transparency and Explainability: Increasing the transparency of LLM algorithms and providing explanations for their outputs can help users understand how the models arrive at their conclusions, making it easier to identify and correct errors or biases 38. This can involve techniques such as providing access to the model’s internal representations or generating explanations for its decisions in natural language.
• Human Oversight and Collaboration: Maintaining human oversight and fostering collaboration between humans and LLMs is essential for ensuring that LLMs are used ethically and effectively. Human experts should be involved in validating LLM outputs, particularly in high-stakes domains, to prevent errors and mitigate potential harms 14. This collaboration can involve a combination of human expertise and AI assistance, where LLMs provide initial analysis or suggestions, and human experts review and validate the outputs before making final decisions.
• Integrating Knowledge Graphs: A key finding from research by Juan Sequeda highlights the potential of integrating knowledge graphs to significantly enhance the accuracy and reliability of LLM-powered systems 39. Knowledge graphs provide a structured and contextualized representation of information, which can help LLMs access and utilize relevant knowledge more effectively, reducing the risk of hallucinations and improving the accuracy of their outputs.

Conclusion: Navigating the Complexities of LLMs

Large language models offer transformative potential across various sectors, but their accuracy limitations and potential for generating misleading information necessitate a cautious and responsible approach to their deployment. By prioritizing data quality, developing robust evaluation metrics, promoting transparency, maintaining human oversight, and integrating knowledge graphs, we can harness the power of LLMs while mitigating their risks and ensuring that their outputs contribute to informed decision-making and positive societal impact.

The increasing integration of LLMs into various aspects of society raises broader ethical considerations. It is crucial to ensure that these models are developed and deployed in a way that aligns with human values, promotes fairness, and respects privacy. This involves addressing potential biases, ensuring accountability for LLM-driven decisions, and fostering transparency in the development and use of these technologies.

As LLMs continue to evolve, ongoing research and critical evaluation will be crucial for navigating the complexities of this technology and ensuring its ethical and beneficial use. This requires collaboration between researchers, developers, policymakers, and users to address the challenges and maximize the potential of LLMs for the betterment of society.

Type of Reasoning	Description	Example
Deductive Reasoning	Drawing specific conclusions from general principles or premises.	If all men are mortal, and Socrates is a man, then Socrates is mortal.
Inductive Reasoning	Generalizing from specific observations to form broader conclusions.	If every swan you’ve ever seen is white, you might conclude that all swans are white.
Abductive Reasoning	Inferring the best explanation for a set of observations.	If you see wet grass, you might abduce that it has rained.
Analogical Reasoning	Identifying similarities between different situations or concepts to draw inferences.	If you know that the Earth revolves around the Sun, you might reason that other planets also revolve around stars.

Works cited

1. Benefits and limits of large language models - web.dev, accessed February 22, 2025, https://web.dev/articles/ai-llms-benefits
2. Primary Risks of Large Language Models: Addressing Hallucinations, Bias and Security, accessed February 22, 2025, https://ralabs.org/blog/primary-risks-of-large-language-models/
3. An Executive’s Guide to the Risks of Large Language Models (LLMs): From Hallucinations to Copyright Infringement - FairNow, accessed February 22, 2025, https://fairnow.ai/executives-guide-risks-of-llms/
4. Risks of Large Language Models: A comprehensive guide - Deepchecks, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.deepchecks.com/risks-of-large-language-models/
5. Top 5 Risks of Large Language Models - Deepchecks, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.deepchecks.com/top-5-risks-of-large-language-models/
6. How To Chose Perfect LLM For The Problem Statement Before Finetuning - Labellerr, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.labellerr.com/blog/how-to-choose-llm-to-suit-for-use-case/
7. Evaluation of Large Language Model Performance and Reliability for Citations and References in Scholarly Writing: Cross-Disciplinary Study, accessed February 22, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11031695/
8. LLMs Are Becoming Less Accurate. Here’s Where Knowledge Graphs Can Help - Fluree, accessed February 22, 2025, https://flur.ee/fluree-blog/llms-are-becoming-less-accurate-heres-where-knowledge-graphs-can-help/
9. What LLM is The Most Accurate? - Originality.ai, accessed February 22, 2025, https://originality.ai/blog/what-llm-is-the-most-accurate
10. The Risks of Overreliance on Large Language Models (LLMs) - Aporia, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.aporia.com/learn/risks-of-overreliance-on-llms/
11. The Larger the LLM, the Less Reliable it Becomes - Customerland, accessed February 22, 2025, https://customerland.net/the-larger-the-llm-the-less-reliable-it-becomes/
12. Study finds health care evaluations of large language models lacking in real patient data and bias assessment - News-Medical, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.news-medical.net/news/20241018/Study-finds-health-care-evaluations-of-large-language-models-lacking-in-real-patient-data-and-bias-assessment.aspx
13. Evaluating the Accuracy of Responses by Large Language Models for Information on Disease Epidemiology, accessed February 22, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11791122/
14. Will Large Language Models Really Change How Work Is Done?, accessed February 22, 2025, https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/will-large-language-models-really-change-how-work-is-done/
15. Can We Count on LLMs? The Fixed-Effect Fallacy and Claims of GPT-4 Capabilities - arXiv, accessed February 22, 2025, https://arxiv.org/html/2409.07638v1
16. New Data on LLM Accuracy - insideAI News, accessed February 22, 2025, https://insideainews.com/2023/12/25/new-data-on-llm-accuracy/
17. A Guide to Prompt Engineering for Reasoning LLM Models like Deepseek R1, OpenAI O3, accessed February 22, 2025, https://medium.com/@sahin.samia/a-guide-to-prompt-engineering-for-reasoning-llm-models-like-deepseek-r1-openai-o3-e6b737266dde
18. Large Language Models pose risk to science with false answers, says Oxford study, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2023-11-20-large-language-models-pose-risk-science-false-answers-says-oxford-study-0
19. 5 key features and benefits of large language models | The Microsoft Cloud Blog, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-cloud/blog/2024/10/09/5-key-features-and-benefits-of-large-language-models/
20. What is the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs)? - Lucent Innovation, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.lucentinnovation.com/blogs/it-insights/large-language-models-llms
21. The Rise Of Large Language Models: A Helping Hand For Healthcare? - Forbes, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbesbusinesscouncil/2024/05/29/the-rise-of-large-language-models-a-helping-hand-for-healthcare/
22. Large Language Models - Benefits, Use Cases, & Types - Yellow.ai, accessed February 22, 2025, https://yellow.ai/blog/large-language-models/
23. The Impact of Large Language Models on Education: Simplifying AI for Better Learning, accessed February 22, 2025, https://integranxt.com/blog/the-impact-of-large-language-models-on-education-simplifying-ai-for-better-learning/
24. Benefits of LLMs in Education – Jen’s Teaching and Learning Hub - Publish, accessed February 22, 2025, https://publish.illinois.edu/teaching-learninghub-byjen/benefits-of-llms-in-education/
25. Large Language Models for Education: A Survey and Outlook - arXiv, accessed February 22, 2025, https://arxiv.org/html/2403.18105v1
26. Impact of Large Language Models on Medical Education and Teaching Adaptations - PMC, accessed February 22, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11294775/
27. Full article: The impact of large language models on university students’ literacy development: a dialogue with Lea and Street’s academic literacies framework - Taylor & Francis Online, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/07294360.2024.2332259
28. Large Language Models in Healthcare: Medical LLM Use Cases - Aisera, accessed February 22, 2025, https://aisera.com/blog/large-language-models-healthcare/
29. Potential of Large Language Models in Health Care: Delphi Study - PMC, accessed February 22, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11130776/
30. Revolutionizing Health Care: The Transformative Impact of Large Language Models in Medicine - Journal of Medical Internet Research, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.jmir.org/2025/1/e59069
31. Revolutionizing Health Care: The Transformative Impact of Large Language Models in Medicine - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed February 22, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11751657/
32. Successful Real-World Use Cases For LLMs (And Lessons They Teach) - Forbes, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbestechcouncil/2024/03/07/successful-real-world-use-cases-for-llms-and-lessons-they-teach/
33. How Large Language Models (LLMs) Can Transform Legal Industry - Custom AI Agents | Springs, accessed February 22, 2025, https://springsapps.com/knowledge/how-large-language-models-llms-can-transform-legal-industry
34. Impact of Large Language Models (LLMs) on Dispute Processes in Law - Secretariat, accessed February 22, 2025, https://secretariat-intl.com/insights/impact-of-large-language-models-llms-on-dispute-processes-in-law/
35. AI sentencing cut jail time for low-risk offenders, but study finds racial …, accessed February 22, 2025, https://freemannews.tulane.edu/2024/01/24/ai-sentencing-cut-jail-time-for-low-risk-offenders-but-study-finds-racial-bias-persisted
36. A reflection on the phenomenon of LLM Model Collapse leading to the decline in AI quality, accessed February 22, 2025, https://levysoft.medium.com/a-reflection-on-the-phenomenon-of-llm-model-collapse-leading-to-the-decline-in-ai-quality-a6993f86866c
37. LLM Evaluation Metrics: The Ultimate LLM Evaluation Guide - Confident AI, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.confident-ai.com/blog/llm-evaluation-metrics-everything-you-need-for-llm-evaluation
38. Evaluating performance of LLM-based Applications | by Anurag Bhagat - Medium, accessed February 22, 2025, https://medium.com/towards-data-science/evaluating-performance-of-llm-based-applications-be6073c02421
39. Increasing the LLM Accuracy for Question Answering on Structured Data: Knowledge Graphs to the Rescu - YouTube, accessed February 22, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2zszW9nESuY